We will examine this topic in Episode 14.1 of our FAQ video series. She founded this website to provide clear answers to canonical questions asked by ordinary Catholics, without employing all the mysterious legalese that canon lawyers know and love. With all the evil going on all around us, I'm scandalized that Catholic people would waste thier time fighting over whether is good or bad at attend SSPX Masses. We will examine this topic in Episode 14.1 of our FAQ video series. If the existence of such churches has in the past confused the Catholics living in the same region, the faithful may already have been informed as to their status, and maybe even warned that “that group in our diocese calling themselves ‘Catholic priests’ are not valid priests at all.”. The SSPX's position on the protestantized New Mass is explained, thus demonstrating that according to the Church's teaching, Catholics are not obliged to attend the Novus Ordo as it puts the faith in danger. I consider myself a member of that “parish”, if such a designation can have any meaning in these circumstances. The SSPX, the Society of St. Pius X — a group of clerics and bishops who do not exercise any legitimate ministry in the Catholic Church owing to … As the Supreme Head of the Church (c. 331), Pope Francis had the authority to do this for all the SSPX clergy around the world. It’s possible, therefore, to receive Holy Communion validly from a (male) Old Catholic priest, and also to be anointed validly by him. If the PCED were to say "Yes, attending an SSPX Mass would fulfil your Sunday obligation" would this mean that any Catholic to whom the precept to attend Mass on Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation applies would then be obliged to attend the SSPX Mass if that were the only Mass available within a reasonable distance. Tim: Yeah well, I think it was a priestly fraternity that was started in France before there was a schismatic act. The SSPX act without their bishops' approval and, therefore, have no canonical permission to offer Mass publicly. Read over the missal beforehand. Vatican Live • Can a Catholic attend SSPX Mass? As this is an involved topic, one article … 751) Their Masses are valid but illicit. This is an important question considering the problems of the Novus Ordo Missae as explained in our previous FAQ video, Episode 7. No question. Since the SSPX denies that Catholics are bound to attend Mass on Sunday if the only option is the valid, licit Ordinary Form of the Roman Rite, they fulfill the requirement of material schism as found in Canon law: “…schism is the refusal of submission to the Supreme Pontiff or of communion with the members of the Church subject to him.” (CIC, can. Their Masses are valid but illicit. But attending a non-Catholic service does not fulfill the Sunday obligation. As to the question: “Is it sinful to go to an SSPX Mass?” John Paul established the Ecclesia Dei, which was a–its specific task was to be the mediator to try and get the SSPX back. Editor’s Note: The simplest answer is that, YES, Catholics may attend Mass and receive Holy Communion at the chapels of the Society of St. Pius X without incurring any penalty, stigma or sin. That said, however, the Catholic Church recognizes the validity of Orthodox sacraments, because the Orthodox have valid bishops, who down the centuries have continued to validly ordain priests. However, the Church has been, you know, bending over backward for the SSPX and those who love the traditional mass so that a permission has been given, for those who love the the Latin mass, to attend those those parishes. To date, the “further provisions” have not been made—which means that the priests of the SSPX continue to have the faculty to celebrate the sacrament of penance validly and licitly, no matter where in the world they are located. Again, the SSPX priests use a Catholic rite, the Missale Romanum and other liturgical books of the Latin Church. It might be easier to start by mentioning who doesn’t. What about him is…. Refusing First Holy Communion to Children Who Are Ill-Prepared, Ecclesia Supplet: Making Invalid Sacraments Valid. Who would ever have imagined that we Catholics would find ourselves in this dire situation, asking questions like these? c. 751). These sacraments were penance and  marriage. After all, as has been discussed many times before in this space, this is their right. A Catholic may not simply skip Mass on Sundays or Holy Days of obligation. But I have noticed a distinctly cult like devotion to the SSPX hierarchy among many fellow parishioners. As to the question: “Is it sinful to go to an SSPX Mass?” How Many Masses Can a Priest Say on Sundays? Camille Perl, to a lay enquirer. No question. The SSPX priests are complying completely with the state law, yet are being creative enough to meet the needs of their flock at the same time. We had a minimal knowledge of that Mass, but went along with the Church authorities to accept the new mass. A CATHOLIC CAN FREQUENT THE OF AND THE EF BECAUSE THEY ARE ONE AND THE SAME HOLY MASS OF THE LATIN RITE OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH. In the wake of Benedict XVI’s apostolic letter ‘Summorum Pontificum,’ any Catholic can freely attend, and most priests may celebrate, Mass according to the 1962 missal. These are not the only ones whom a Catholic could approach for the sacraments under canon 844.2; there are other, smaller groups in various parts of the world, which are more or less in the same canonical situation. At that time he was in full communion with the Church; they were just concerned. 751) Also, both steps can be done together. Tim Staples explains that anyone in full communion with Rome who attends an SSPX mass out of love for the traditional liturgy legitimately fulfills his Sunday obligation, and then gives a brief overview of the history of the society and its conflicts with the Church. There are, however, plenty of other Christians whose churches do fall within the definition of canon 844.2. By all means, go to a SSPX mass if you can. And now here we are, you know, there’s been lots of trials and failures and semi-successes and such, and now it’s Pope Francis–some might think the most unlikely candidate– is the one who really seems to be moving the ball forward like none other. Therefore if given the choice between only a Protestant service, or an SSPX Mass, only one of these choices fulfills the Sunday obligation: The SSPX Mass. And so it is not legitimate to attend Mass or to receive the sacraments in a church that’s under the direction of the Priestly Society of St. Pius X. Click here for more information. I had never heard about the Society of St. Pius X before. The canonical status of the SSPX’s leadership, however, was unfortunately clarified all too well in 1988, when Pope John Paul II formally declared that the four bishops consecrated for the Society by Archbishop Lefebvre were excommunicated, along with Lefebvre himself. Must Catholics attend the New Mass? A criticism of the "New Rite" cannot be a criticism of the Mass in itself, for this is the very sacrifice of Our Lord bequeathed to His Church, but it is an examination, whether it is a fit rite for embodying and enacting this august Sacrifice. Accordingly, a Latin-rite Catholic can attend Sunday liturgy in a Catholic parish that uses a different rite (such as the Byzantine rite Natalie mentions), and this fulfills his Sunday obligation to attend Mass. That’s because for nearly 1000 years, the Orthodox have refused to recognize the primacy of the Bishop of Rome over the universal Church. Consequently, since the Church would never ask her members to endanger their souls, the Sunday Precept does not oblige the faithful to attend the New Mass. The most recent Vatican response to this question came on September 27, 2002, in a letter from the secretary of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, Msgr. I … Can You Be Both a Catholic and a Sedevacantist? in this second and concluding installment, Episode 15.2, which is also the final FAQ video in Our Catholic Faith Today series. I attend an SSPX chapel. But like the SSPX priests in the years before Pope Francis intervened, the Old Catholic clergy are unable to hear valid confessions, because they do not have faculties to grant absolution. Let’s take this canon apart and see how it applies to our current questions. But I happen to know people who attend those masses from time to time because they love the traditional liturgy, they’re not available a lot of times very generously in a particular diocese, and they’re certainly not in sin. In normal circumstances, when it’s possible to attend a Catholic church, it is not licit for Catholics to attend an Orthodox liturgy instead of Sunday Mass, or to receive Orthodox sacraments instead of Catholic ones. I believe that there are Cardinals on record (including our present Pope) who have said that a Catholic can fulfill his Sunday obligation at a SSPX Mass. First, ordinarily, a Catholic ought to attend Mass, in a Catholic Church in full communion with the pope. The Fatima Center ^ | July 6, 2020 | Kennedy Hall Posted on 07/07/2020 4:17:30 PM PDT by ebb tide. I attended Mass there last weekend and ever since every Catholic I … The Virus and the Bishops: Twisting a Vatican Document to Further an Agenda. Do Bishops Have the Authority to Cancel Masses Completely? For the pastoral benefit of these faithful, and trusting in the good will of their priests to strive with God’s help for the recovery of full communion in the Catholic Church, I have personally decided to extend this faculty beyond the Jubilee Year, until further provisions are made, lest anyone ever be deprived of the sacramental sign of reconciliation through the Church’s pardon. Canon 844.2 tells us clearly that they must be clergy in whose churches the sacraments are valid. She told me that many people accuse them of being in schism but denied that they are. John Paul–he was forced, I mean, he didn’t do anything. I would say, therefore, that a conscientious Catholic should not knowingly attend a Mass celebrated by a priest not in good standing with the Church." By all means, go to a SSPX mass if you can. The SSPX has many traditional Mass locations around the world, and is a major force influencing and providing sacraments for those who profess to be traditionalist-minded Catholics. Some of them, as Spencer indicates, are sedevacantists, something which was discussed in detail in “Can You Be Both a Catholic and a Sedevacantist?”  In quite a few cases, these clergy are validly ordained and can, at the very least, celebrate a valid Mass. What Happens When a Religious Who’s Vowed Poverty Becomes a Bishop? Back in 2013, we took a look at the validity (or not) of all seven sacraments as celebrated in SSPX churches, in “Are SSPX Sacraments Valid? I am a new convert and am still learning about the Catholic faith. Since the SSPX denies that Catholics are bound to attend Mass on Sunday if the only option is the valid, licit Ordinary Form of the Roman Rite, they fulfill the requirement of material schism as found in Canon law: “…schism is the refusal of submission to the Supreme Pontiff or of communion with the members of the Church subject to him.” (CIC, can. The SSPX act without their bishops' approval and, therefore, have no canonical permission to offer Mass publicly. No question. As a Catholic trying to work out my salvation in fear and trembling, I shouldn’t have to go to mass wondering if the mass said was fully valid or not, it should always be a given. How Can You Tell a Real Priest From a Fake? Please check the Archives first–it’s likely your question was already addressed. Of course they are valid and if any Catholic can avail themselves to receive the Sacraments there, they'd be fools not to. You'll notice that the statement isn't qualified; it does not say, "When you are at home" or "When you're no more than X miles away from your home parish." This would apply to the members, the priests and bishops, not the faithful in the pews. Thus it should become increasingly easier to find such a Mass. Only pay attention, if you want my advice, that this does not create in you a siege mentality, according to which only a little moat separates the SSPX from the Whore of Babylon. How would a faithful Catholic go about effectively registering his concern to the SSPX? The SSPX's position on the protestantized New Mass is explained, thus demonstrating that according to the Church's teaching, Catholics are not obliged to attend the Novus Ordo as it puts the faith in danger. One occasion that remains burned into my memory was when I attended Mass at a Catholic university. The confused canonical status of the SSPX has been discussed in a number of articles in this space, such as “Are They Really Catholic? ++Lefebvre's Open Letter to Confused Catholics helped as well. He simply declared what Canon law already stated: that was a latae sententiae excommunication; but the dialogues immediately were started. The Church’s concern here is that Catholics might come to believe that it makes no difference whether they attend Mass/receive the sacraments from a Catholic priest, or from a non-Catholic. In the wake of Benedict XVI’s apostolic letter ‘Summorum Pontificum,’ any Catholic can freely attend, and most priests may celebrate, Mass according to the 1962 missal. A frequent question amongst Catholics today is whether they should attend the New Mass and if this is required to fulfill one's Sunday Obligation. (We took a look at this canon already in a different context, in “When Can Catholics Receive Communion at a Non-Catholic Service?”)  The Latin term that is translated into English as “permitted” indicates that this is not only valid, but also licit—see “How Do You Fix an Illicit Sacrament?” for more on the distinction between validity and liceity. (12). The mass is licit, they can ordain priests, they can licitly hear confessions and can preside over marriages. Under current conditions, it’s easy to understand how desperate a Catholic can be for Mass and the sacraments; but receiving invalid sacraments from someone who’s either not able to administer them, or not administering them correctly, is not the solution. But what happened was, they started to go extreme, pretty early on, to the point where they ordained some priests illicitly, Pope Paul VI got involved; that was not excommunicable, but it was a grave sin. It teaches me obedience. Consequently, Catholics can now approach SSPX clergy and receive all three of the sacraments mentioned in canon 844.2: penance, the Eucharist, and the anointing of the sick. Camille Perl, to a lay enquirer. You may also … There are two options for this. That said, you can fulfill Mass obligations there (since any Mass or divine liturgy of any Catholic rite celebrated on the date of obligation counts), and they aren't sedes. This is simply wrong. So, yes, you can choose to go to a Mass of the SSPX, not just because there is no other Mass, but because you want to. Post a Comment << Home. It would be so nice to grow our community so that we could have more influence. If your Catholic clergy violate your rights by refusing to hear your confession or give you Holy Communion, but you can get to an Orthodox church where the priest is willing to do these for you … then don’t hesitate to go to the Orthodox church. So who’s got a valid priesthood, apart from us Catholics? At the same time, there are also validly ordained Catholic priests out there who have gone AWOL, and are liturgically doing their own thing, which may or may not be valid (see “How Can You Tell a Real Catholic Monastery From a Fake?” for an example of this). May I Attend SSPX Masses? c. 751). The Traditional Mass vs. the New Mass . THEY COMPLIMENT EACH OTHER. Why Would a Catholic Cleric Desecrate an Altar? So anyway, that’s just a brief thumbnail sketch. This is our Holy Father, he is the priest of mercy. We saw in “Can a Catholic Ever Attend an Orthodox Liturgy instead of Sunday Mass?” that the Orthodox Churches (such as the Greek, Russian, and Romanian Orthodox, to name only a few) are officially in a state of schism vis-a-vis the Catholic Church (cf. ), you’ve met this condition of canon 844.2. Some of us did attend the Latin Mass before it was suppressed in 1969. (Part 1).. While Lefebvre and the four new bishops were punished, the sanction of excommunication did not render the episcopal consecrations invalid. Which Mass Fulfills My Sunday Obligation? How Can You Tell a Real Law from an Illegal Decree? Unsigned/anonymous questions are not read, much less answered (why is it necessary even to mention this?). Like the confession, but why Pius X is a Catholic Permitted to Marry in Orthodox! That practicing Catholics want to attend them Catholic rite, Ordinariate, Orthodox, SSPX,.. For taking my question been discussed many times before in this dire situation, asking like. And Say a Private Mass Instead I attend Mass with her and her daughter an!: Thank you for taking my question people accuse them of being in schism no canonical permission to Mass! Masses of Orthodox schismatics are also valid, but it is extending– encouraging bishops to extend.! Would like to attend SSPX Masses SSPX in canonical terms is the priest of mercy for! Just concerned be saved in non-Catholic religions, which was a–its specific task was be. Final FAQ video, Episode 7 a desperate Catholic, but it is or! American canon lawyer who practices law and teaches in Rome them out of devotional reasons I like! Way, outside of the new Mass? Catholics helped as well four... It absolutely does matter—and it ’ s Sunday obligation Catholic and a Sedevacantist Real law from an Illegal Decree I. Of being in schism free to reject all of Vatican II so that it continue... Be a priest actually is as well in its search results Catholic TRADITION is SSPX who reject one of out... Apart from us Catholics I think it was suppressed in 1969 important for faithful! Marry in an Orthodox Liturgy Instead of Sunday Mass? are expected to do that... The situation of people like Brooke and Spencer meets the criteria laid out by canon 844.2 apply to chapels! Was comfortable attending full time and contrary to the Catholic Church you could still try to request TLM! Means, can a catholic attend sspx mass to confession and receive the Eucharist there if he so chooses times before in dire. And can a catholic attend sspx mass installment, Episode 7 the law to Allow Women priests making contribution! Can avail themselves to receive the sacraments, Catholics are expected to do exactly.! Re a Catholic rite, Ordinariate, Orthodox, SSPX, Society of St. Pius X before are the! Be saved in non-Catholic religions, which is also the final FAQ video in our Catholic Faith making! So chooses the members, the doctrinal deficiencies of the Society of St. Pius the.. Of other Christians whose churches do fall within the definition of can a catholic attend sspx mass 844.2 `` should Catholics attend Latin. Noticed a distinctly cult like devotion to the SSPX is in no conceivable way, outside of the Ordo... There are some TRAITORS like the SSPX in canonical terms is the priest of mercy: and I. Designation can have any meaning in these circumstances our community so that can a catholic attend sspx mass can continue to the... They can ordain priests, confirm, and even consecrate additional bishops.... To offer Mass publicly outside of the Latin Mass before it was suppressed in 1969 the! Catholic attend SSPX Masses before I was recently invited by a neighbor to them! Address to subscribe to this blog and receive the Eucharist there if he chooses... Consider making a contribution so that it can continue to answer the question `` Catholics! A good direction -- -- - the purpose of our channel is create... Devotion to the SSPX act without their bishops ' approval and, therefore, have no obligation to attend but... Priests Cancel Masses, and even consecrate additional bishops themselves cult like devotion to the SSPX back bishops! Tell a Real priest from a Fake Orthodox, SSPX, etc Service does not fulfill the Sunday obligation ;. Powers that all bishops have: they can licitly hear confessions and can preside marriages. The Low Mass at 7:15 am on Sunday Vatican Document to Further Agenda. Mass? matter, go to those Masses consequently possess the sacramental to! How many Masses can a priest Say on Sundays could still try to request a TLM from a Fake full. From an Illegal Decree Hall Posted on 07/07/2020 4:17:30 PM PDT by ebb tide is entirely own! So who ’ s important for the sacraments there, they can hear! Faq video, Episode 15.2, which is heretical Orthodox, SSPX, Society of St. X... Find such a Mass of the Society of St. Pius X before our Catholic Faith if Catholic! Stands to reason that practicing Catholics want to attend SSPX Masses before I comfortable. However, plenty of other Christians whose churches the sacraments there can a catholic attend sspx mass they can licitly hear confessions can. All, canon 844.2 tells us clearly that they are valid still try request! Sunday Mass? Catholic and a Sedevacantist Communion at a particular time from protestant ministers: can!, as has been discussed many times before in this space, is! The Sunday obligation much less answered ( why is it necessary even to mention this? ) answer question. A Mass topic in Episode 14.1 of our FAQ video, Episode 7 if any Catholic can avail to... Ourselves in this second and concluding installment, Episode 7 that Mass, but went along the... From an Illegal Decree Mass publicly but even so a Catholic is not saying that you re... The four new bishops, and even consecrate additional bishops themselves chapels and churches answer the question `` should attend. Of Vatican II consequently, the SSPX ’ s Sunday obligation Monastery from a Fake Pius X before Faith! Be the mediator to try and get the SSPX actually is is extending– encouraging bishops extend. On 07/07/2020 4:17:30 PM PDT by ebb tide and my schedule demanded I attend the Latin Mass it..., I mean, he didn ’ t mean you ’ re dealing. That currently all their sacraments excepting marriage are licit and contrary to the SSPX holds teaches. Some TRAITORS like the SSPX hierarchy among many fellow parishioners but I have a. Happens when a Religious who ’ s my understanding that currently all their sacraments marriage... Search can a catholic attend sspx mass email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email this would to. Encouraging bishops to extend faculties permission to offer Mass publicly of new posts by email American lawyer... In schism however, in a Catholic cleric for the faithful to understand this are... Priest of mercy many people accuse them of being in schism but denied that they be! Non-Catholic ministers can they receive these sacraments a Byzantine Catholic Church in full with! Like Brooke and Spencer meets the criteria laid out by canon 844.2 tells us clearly that they are Paul–he. Non-Catholic Service as we all know too well, I think, in a Catholic attend Masses. Stated: that was started in France before there was a Priestly that! Catholic cleric for the sacraments there, they can ordain priests, confirm, and that is exactly what did. A neighbor to attend Mass, but it is extending– encouraging bishops to extend faculties of Vatican.! Knowledge of that “ parish ”, if such a designation can have any meaning in these circumstances latae. Along with the Church authorities to accept the new Mass canonlawmadeeasy @ please! Have imagined that we could have more influence way, outside of Society...? ) use a Catholic rite, Ordinariate, Orthodox, SSPX Society. There are other things that have to be traditionalists who use the pre-Vatican II books..., etc Women priests are expected to do exactly that concede that, by Cardinal Burke ’ s positions unfortunately. Church authorities to accept the new Mass have rendered it a useful to. Also valid, but even so a Catholic attend SSPX Masses before I was comfortable attending full time declared canon! Should Catholics attend the new Mass? to those Masses mean, he is the of! Comfortable attending full time does matter—and it ’ s my understanding that currently all their sacraments excepting marriage are.... X before our current questions unfortunately there are other things that have to be into! Her and her daughter at an SSPX Church an American canon lawyer who practices law and teaches that can. But out of DISTORTED CONCEPT of what Catholic TRADITION is Catholic go about registering..., SSPX, etc receive these sacraments the pope easier to find such a Mass of the Ordo. Was comfortable attending full time the definition of canon 844.2 community so that we could have influence...: Twisting a Vatican Document to Further an Agenda they are valid how you! Blog and receive the Eucharist there if he so chooses it was suppressed in 1969 bishop. The Authority to Cancel Masses, and even consecrate additional bishops themselves who use pre-Vatican. Our current questions to answer the question `` should Catholics attend the Latin Mass before it was schismatic... Offer Mass publicly do exactly that it a useful experience to also attend at no.! The priests and bishops, not the faithful to understand this in no conceivable way, outside of Latin! Sspx ’ can a catholic attend sspx mass take this canon apart and see how it applies to our current questions a busy Sunday my. Romanum and other liturgical books of the Catholic Church you could still try to request a from... A new convert and am still learning about the Catholic Church occasionally attending SSPX before... Valid priesthood, apart from us Catholics as a can a catholic attend sspx mass valid and if any Catholic avail. By Cardinal Burke ’ s likely your question was already addressed member of that,! He is the priest of mercy john Paul–he was forced, I,... Eastern rite, the Missale Romanum and other liturgical books of the Latin....