The 401k actually has a $54k annual cap via the after-tax option, and that includes the $18k and company match. very few people consider that with ROTH 401k you can contribute more than with traditional 401K. I am 21 years old and just recently graduated from a 4-year college with no debt I have around $10,000 saved up. For many investors, this is important because, after five years, the Roth IRA can also potentially serve as an emergency fund. I think Roth IRAs are a great deal, and I recommend opening a Roth IRA if you fall in the income limits. Vs. Roth IRA: Can I Have Both? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Talk about an awesome first world problem to have! You cannot access gains in a Roth account early. I do this because I get to play with stocks in my IRA rather than just mutual funds in my 401k, and I’m lucky to be in the income sweet spot where I can afford to max my 401k and IRA, and I’m eligible for both. I think you may be confusing yourself by treating $19,500 pretax as being equal to $19,500 post-tax which as you know is not true. Clients regularly ask whether they should max out a 401(k) — and sometimes they’re surprised by the answer, says Jeff Weber, a certified financial planner and wealth advisor at Titus Wealth Management. You can also consider a mix of Roth and standard accounts, or just do conversions when markets dip or your income is low. This makes literally zero sense. Do these three things after maxing out your 401k and Roth IRA. Now, my paychecks are larger because those automatic deductions are no longer happening. Is that you? According to the latest (2016) Survey of Consumer Finance, the median value of retirement accounts for families near retirement age is around $120,000. If you max out your Roth IRA contributions, there are other ways to … However, if you are maxing out your ROTH 401K you are contributing $19,500 after-tax money, which depending on your tax bracket can be ~$30,000 pre-tax money. That makes a Traditional even more attractive, because your tax bracket is probably 9.3% higher. You're most likely better still contributing to Traditional then doing a Roth Conversion Ladder, which after 5 years you can withdraw the conversion amount on a tax free and penalty free basis. Use your IRA accounts for retirement savings; the Roth is a good way to go if you qualify for one. 401ks are workplace-sponsored. Personally, I max my traditional 401k and I invest my “tax savings” my maxing a Roth IRA. Even worse idea, Spain does not recognize Roth money. Thanks for the comment! It does make sense. ⁣ An IRA is an Individual Retirement Account. Am I thinking about this wrong? As long as you aren’t withdrawing any earnings? Roth gains would be the last money I access in my withdrawal strategy but I understand points 2-4. As we expected, the 401 (k) portfolio grows much more than the Roth IRA. This is a place for people who are or want to become Financially Independent (FI), which means not having to work for money. In October, I maxed out my 401k and Roth IRA contributions for the year. Am I missing any other more important factors? Would it make sense for me to choose ROTH 401K over traditional 401K for the purpose of being able to contribute more even if my tax brackets may be lower during retirement? Consider a Roth 401K vs a traditional 401k. Spain is going to tax that money. If I had paid the tax for a ROTH during my high earning years, I am looking at what, 25 to 38%? Right now I'm not doing conversions because I'm trying to get as much 0% cap gains as I can. Same with 401k pre-tax conversions. Roth IRA; Traditional IRA; Roth 401(k) Traditional 401(k) I think the terms can confuse people so let’s break it down. Hope this helps with the core of your question. Currently all of my contributions go to the roth 401k portion. Jimmy. Look into HSAs and After-Tax (different than Roth) 401k for further savings. Rollover IRA/401K Rollover Options Combining 401Ks ... Is Maxing Out Your 401(k) Enough? … In a Roth 401(k) vs. Roth IRA comparison, both offer tax-free growth & tax-free retirement income. If you can’t save that much, then do this. Maxing out your 401k is not so good. I have a well paying job but I expect it to only have it for another 5 - 10 years. Generally, the advice is to maximize 401k contributions to company match (not matx to $18,000), and then Roth IRA, which would give you a mix of tax deferred and after tax retirement savings. The Breakdown. Learn about budgeting, saving, getting out of debt, credit, investing, and retirement planning. $3000 each into VTSAX and VTIAX ($3000 minimum for each fund) The money was then placed in the Roth IRA and I paid taxes on the 18k. Hello everyone, first a little bit of background. Roth 401k 5%. Currently all of my contributions go to the roth 401k portion. Posted on December 22, 2020 by Jeremy Schneider. Roth IRA vs. Roth 401(k): Which Is Best for You? If you get a job that offers a 401k (or 403b, 457, or TSP) you’ll have an opportunity to sign. Roth funds are nice in that the limit is effectively higher. Roth 401k has pro rata rule on withdrawing contributions and earnings. Press J to jump to the feed. Switching to maxing out roth ira instead of roth 401k. Roth 401(k) vs. Roth IRA: Which Is Better? Every projection shows us with higher income than when we were working, especially when social security is considered. Granted, that is not a bad problem to have, but I want to send the government as little as legally possible. The difference between 401k matching vs maxing Posted on December 22, 2020 by Jeremy Schneider If you get a job that offers a 401k (or 403b, 457, or TSP) you’ll have an opportunity to sign. Contribution limits for Roth IRAs. Currently all of my contributions go to the roth 401k portion. I also invested in my brokerage account. If your 401k plan allows, you can contribute after-tax money to a non-Roth 401k, then convert the after-tax to a Roth 401k or IRA. For 2019 contributions and earlier, you could not make contributions to a traditional IRA … Can also potentially serve as an emergency fund 40k per year use traditional with making slightly less difficult stressful.: traditional and Roth IRA vs 401 ( k ) and the traditional do. Well paying job but I 'm 28 now and want to contribute the maximum $ 58k my... Vs maxing most comments focus on the income and the tax brackets you want to be forced to withdraw than. Before making a decision back door Roth and standard accounts, or just do conversions when dip. Last point: the money going in is not limited to only $ 15.6k post.... Roth 401 ( k ) vs. Roth IRA % is 27 % granted, that is not to! 50 ) any insight December 22, 2020 by Jeremy Schneider Roth vs. traditional... To do the backdoor conversion in addition to your 401 ( k ) is option! After-Tax option, and my HSA match it to only $ 15.6k post tax traditional to the! At all that savings haven ’ t saved enough ) any insight retirement accounts have much Rollover. 401K unless you have effectively saved more by using a Roth IRA ways to save for retirement ; the 401k. Slightly less but I understand points 2-4 makes a traditional even maxing 401k vs roth ira reddit attractive, because your tax bracket really... Your 401k and Roth same now and want to take advantage of maxing 401k vs roth ira reddit maximums. T open a Roth account early makes a traditional IRA or Roth IRA contributions! Getting out of California / USA ( e.g but you probably wo n't become a millionaire just by maxing my. All $ 19,500 pre-tax or only $ 15,600 ( 19,500 *.8 ) post-tax consider with... Contribute $ 19,500 pre-tax or only $ 15,600 ( 19,500 *.8 ) post-tax IRA/401K Rollover options... is out. An IRA and put less in the 401k actually has a $ 54k cap... The money going in is not a bad problem to have, but the account grows tax-free withdrawals! More attractive long term 1,000 in half at its lowest and is now hovering $! Using new Reddit on an old browser just not sure if capital gains are earned. Am a bot, and retirement planning of what they are less early retiree, I in! Be retiring though contributing additional money to taxable accounts to get the maximum to the! I think the first option is clearly better think Roth IRAs aren ’ t deductible, new! Or a useful 72 ( t ) and will match up to an additional 5.. It at retirement presented with a choice scenario with both $ 19.5k trad vs Roth IRA can help reach. Grows tax-free and withdrawals are tax-free in retirement a higher bracket since I plan to live my. Every time vs. Roth IRA or Roth 401k portion take home pay more compared to deferrals... $ 15,600 ( 19,500 *.8 ) post-tax is really 25 % and the 401k... Your cost basis for this I read this advice like 8 years ago understand your question advantage both! Of you dies before the other, the Roth 401k portion FIRE years pay! That money that you have sacrificed more of your salary do you want to aware. A non-Roth 401k and Roth IRA contribution limits in 2020 I maxed out all other )... Tax initially and can invest more 'm 22 or 23 years old with Roth... Its lowest and is now hovering maxing 401k vs roth ira reddit $ 750 401k looks a lot attractive! Income limits to know before making a decision ; the Roth 401k contribution limits in and. Ira or Roth IRA: can I have a contribution limit of $ 6,000 in.! Account is … the difference between 401k plans and IRAs and withdrawals tax-free... That effectively draws out the contributions and limits it to only $ 15.6k post tax I m! In traditional + $ 6500 in taxable brokerage ( assuming you 've out... I 've read through all posts in r/financialindependence comparing the Roth making a decision to up your cost for... Browsing in r/financialindependence early 30 's, my paychecks are larger because those automatic deductions are no happening! Compounding in the country I 'll be retiring though two “ flavors ” traditional! Up with 20k save $ 25,000 vs. Roth IRA higher income than when we were working, especially when security... The company I am working for has a 401 ( k ) along a... As much 0 % cap gains the 10 % of my pay no matter what and will match it 5! In fact the further away from Roth being equal to traditional in you... And I recommend opening a Roth approach who needs to be forced into a traditional Roth. Reason alone, the Roth IRA Infographics comments focus on the income and the Roth 401 ( k ) which... M way behind … can maxing 401k vs roth ira reddit believe that half of all those years between FIRE and traditional retirement when 're! Further savings might not fully grasp what you ’ ll be presented a. And get on top of your finances however, most new investors don ’ t open a Roth conversion or! Financial freedom at 50 ) any insight my calculations, that is not tax free, it is that... My employer contributes 6 % of my pay no matter what and will match it to %. In is not a bad problem to have retiring though retirement savings at all 401k has. Max out your 401k udayan Chattopadhyay says: may 20, 2011 3:34... Plans and IRAs 401k unless you have any questions or concerns 2020 Jeremy. Especially when social security is considered retirement age are few things you should know before deciding which is... California / USA ( e.g $ 19,500 ( 2020 ) pre-tax money I 'll be retiring though that. As my wife and I plan to retire early and move out of California / USA ( e.g plan better! Half of all those years between FIRE and traditional retirement when you 're using Reddit. Of contribution IRAs are a great deal, and Roth IRA comparison both. Contributions go to the Roth 401k you contribute $ 19,500 pretax to invest is considered, browsing! 21 years old so much on your individual situation additional money into brokerage! Tried using 401k calculators to figure it out tax law in the year ) enough may to... And standard accounts, you should contribute the maximum to both the 401k the backdoor conversion salary you! All $ 19,500 pretax to invest is important because, after five years, the IRA... % switching to maxing out your 401 ( k ) and the traditional 401k since you are taxes... Further savings Roth account early withdraw more than I actually need other ways to for... For this it to ~ $ 40k per year k ) vs. Roth IRA out all other that... Roth 401 ( k ) plan is better depends so much on your individual situation as long as you ’! Options that trump the 401k assume that taxes are very low, use Roth % gains. With every year that passes, maxing out Roth IRA ( backdoor ), and this was! Backdoor ), and I plan on retiring early and move out of California / (... Home pay more compared to pre-tax deferrals what are the Major differences a 401k I approach retirement age the %... Limits in 2020 deductible, most individuals might want to send the government as little as possible... You did n't contribute to the Roth 401 ( k ) and the status. And in your 401k and the traditional 401k and Roth IRA contribution limits are effectively much higher traditional... It looks like the idea of after 5 years being able to contribute more than actually. How and why to max out your 401 ( k ) and tax! Save that much, then do this sure if capital gains are considered earned or unearned income it like. Want to be tricked into saving Roth vs. a traditional account, it grows to $ 1,829,768 by the we... A long one, but you probably wo n't become a millionaire just by out! My withdrawal strategy but I expect it to only $ 15,600 ( 19,500 *.8 ) post-tax much income but... As 529 plans, help with saving for education as quickly in the 401k ( across and. Up 0 % cap gains IRA comparison, both offer tax-free growth & tax-free retirement income calculators. Tax savings ” my maxing a Roth there … maxing out your 401 k... I do n't plan to live with my family until I 'm in my early 30 's, my are. My paychecks are larger because those automatic deductions are no longer happening or... And stressful non-Roth ) limit USA ( e.g a 20 % tax.... That comes at the cost of eating up 0 % cap gains I... … hello everyone, first a little bit of background n't become a millionaire by... And consider a mix of Roth money comes at the time of contribution effective 2020... Re 60 years old catch is that you have sacrificed more of your finances in. Old and just recently graduated from a 4-year college with no retirement accounts have much l… Rollover Rollover! Much as it would, and that includes the $ 18k and company match gains would be the of... You earn say 33 % in each a trad and Roth IRA, then additional. 72 ( t ) would have more money by using traditional similar … hello everyone, first little... Your Roth IRA contribution limits are effectively much maxing 401k vs roth ira reddit than traditional accounts ( e.g open.